Guide
How to choose a neurosurgeon and a practice
Practical steps to check a surgeon's credentials, understand a recommendation, and judge the hospital or practice where you would have care.
You do not need medical training to check a surgeon's background or to ask good questions. This guide covers three areas: credentials, the recommendation, and the place where you would have surgery. A printable checklist goes with it.
1. Credentials
Medical license. Each state has a medical board that licenses doctors and handles complaints. Most boards have free online doctor profiles. At a minimum, these show whether a license is current and any disciplinary history. The Federation of State Medical Boards also runs DocInfo, a free national lookup. It shows a doctor's license history, disciplinary actions, medical school, and specialty board certification. [1]
Board certification. In the United States, the American Board of Neurological Surgery (ABNS) certifies neurosurgeons. Check certification on the board's own website, where you can search by name and state. [2]
A surgeon who finished training recently may not be certified yet. The ABNS calls this "tracking toward certification," also known as "board eligible." The board lists these surgeons on its website, and only certified surgeons may say they are certified. Ask where the surgeon is in that process. [3]
Experience with your problem. Credentials tell you a surgeon is trained. They do not tell you how often the surgeon treats your condition. Ask directly.
2. The recommendation and the surgeon's experience
You can use these questions word for word:
- "What do you expect this to improve for me?"
- "What are my other options?"
- "How often do you perform this procedure for people with my condition?"
- "Who performs the key parts of the operation?"
The American College of Surgeons also lists questions on why the operation is needed, how it is done, the risks, anesthesia, recovery, the surgeon's experience, the facility, and cost. [4]
When a surgeon quotes results, ask three things:
- What was measured? Pain relief, walking distance, and "success" are different things.
- Over what period? Results at 6 weeks and at 5 years can differ.
- In which patients? Results in simple cases may not apply to complex ones.
Second opinions. When there is time, a second opinion is a normal part of care, and a good surgeon will not be offended. Ask the first office for your records, the radiology reports, and the images themselves on a disc or through an online portal. Under a federal privacy law (HIPAA), you have the right to see and get copies of your health records, including X-rays and other images. Your doctor usually has up to 30 days to provide them and may charge a reasonable fee. You can also ask that copies be sent directly to someone else you choose. [5]
In an emergency there may be no time for a second opinion. Ask the team what cannot wait and why.
3. The practice and the hospital
Ask where the surgery would take place, and then ask about that place:
- Teams. Is there a team that regularly cares for people having this operation, including anesthesia and nursing?
- Intensive care. Is there an intensive care unit on site? If not, what is the transfer plan?
- After hours. Whom do I call at night or on a weekend, and who answers?
- Rehabilitation. Is therapy arranged before I leave the hospital?
- Language. Are interpreters available for visits and for consent?
- Cost. Is the surgeon in my insurance network? What about the hospital, anesthesia, and imaging? Can I get a written estimate?
Quality scores. Find out what a score describes before you rely on it. Medicare's Care Compare tool shows data about hospitals. [6] A hospital score is not a score for a specialty program, and neither is a score for one surgeon.
Online reviews. Reviews can tell you about wait times, staff courtesy, and how well the office communicates. They are feedback about patient experience. They do not measure surgical skill or outcomes.
A note about this site
This site is owned by a practicing neurosurgeon. See About and editorial policy for how the pages are written and for conflicts of interest. This guide applies to every surgeon, including the site's owner.
Sources
- Information for consumers. Guide to Medical Regulation in the United States. Federation of State Medical Boards. Open source
- Verify certification. American Board of Neurological Surgery. Open source
- Rules and regulations (Rule 6.10: tracking toward certification, also called board eligible). American Board of Neurological Surgery. Open source
- 10 questions to ask before having an operation. American College of Surgeons. Open source
- Your rights under HIPAA: individuals' right to access health information. US Department of Health and Human Services. Published July 31, 2026. Open source
- Hospital quality initiative: public reporting. Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services. (Hospital data are shown in Care Compare on Medicare.gov.) Open source